Logbook · publication

Smart MOT Failure Rates by Model (2024 Data)

28.5% of Smart MOT tests fail first time. Every model ranked, with age-adjusted scores from 74,285 tests.

Smart MOT Failure Rates by Model (2024 Data)

Direct answer: In 2024, 28.5% of Smart MOT tests ended in a first-time fail, from 74,285 tests, against 28.3% for all makes. Allowing for the age of the vehicles, Smart scores 95 on our MOT index, where 100 is average: better than average. That places it 18 of 41 makes with 20,000 or more tests.

"Fail first time" follows DVSA's definition of an initial failure: a fail, or a pass only after a defect was repaired during the test.

Smart MOT fail rates by model

ModelTestsFail first timeMOT index (100 = average for age)At 4 to 6 yearsAt 10 to 12 yearsMedian mileage
ForTwo44,97928.0%8815.5%27.6%47,300
ForFour22,70326.7%11519.6%n/a39,400

Models with fewer than 5,000 tests in 2024 are not shown. A blank age column means fewer than 500 tests at that age.

Best and worst Smart at MOT time

Among Smart models with 20,000 or more tests, the ForTwo does best for its age (index 88, 28.0% fail first time) and the ForFour does worst (index 115, 26.7%).

What Smart vehicles fail on

Fault areaFailed Smart testsAll failed testsDifference
Lamps, reflectors and electrical36.6%38.9%-2.3 pts
Suspension25.9%31.0%-5.1 pts
Tyres23.4%22.7%+0.6 pts
Brakes21.3%23.9%-2.6 pts
Visibility20.4%16.4%+4.0 pts

Buying a used Smart?

Check any registration free with our MOT history checker.

Compare every make and model in the MOT Failure Index.

FAQs

What percentage of Smart vehicles fail their MOT?

In 2024, 28.5% of Smart MOT tests ended in a first-time fail, from 74,285 tests. The average for all makes was 28.3%.

Which Smart is best at passing the MOT?

Among Smart models with 20,000 or more tests, the ForTwo has the best age-adjusted record, with an MOT index of 88 where 100 is average.

What do Smart vehicles fail the MOT on?

Most often lamps and electrics (36.6% of failed tests), then suspension (25.9%) and tyres (23.4%).

About this data

Every class 4 MOT test recorded by DVSA in 2024, grouped into model families. The MOT index compares first-time fails with the number expected for vehicles of the same ages; it does not adjust for mileage or use. Full method on the index page.

Source: DVSA, anonymised MOT tests and results, 2024. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Analysis by Logbook.co.uk.

Miss a deadline, pay the fine.

One email a week. Every new rule, deadline and record-keeping change that affects you.

Logbook.co.uk is an independent UK publication edited by Jamie Dawson. Guides are checked against current UK legislation and primary sources from gov.uk, HSE, ICO, DVLA, DVSA, CAA and trade bodies. Always confirm against the underlying source before acting. Nothing on this site is legal advice.