MOT Failure Index 2024: Which Cars Fail Most? 244 Models Ranked from 33 Million Tests
Every MOT test of 2024, analysed: 244 models and 41 makes ranked on a fair, age-adjusted index, with the faults they fail on.
Direct answer: 28.3% of MOT tests on cars and light vans ended in a first-time fail in 2024: 9,349,756 of 33,061,372 tests. Age is the biggest factor: 12.7% fail at three years old and 41.5% at thirteen and over. Once age is allowed for, the best-performing high-volume car is the Porsche 911 and the worst is the Citroen DS3. The most common reason for failing is lighting and electrics, found in 38.9% of failed tests.
The Logbook.co.uk MOT Failure Index is built from every MOT test DVSA recorded in 2024 and published as open data. It covers 244 model families and 41 makes. Published 10 November 2026.
Look up any model
Search by make or model, or tap a column heading to sort. MOT index is the fair comparison: 100 is the average for vehicles of the same age, lower is better.
| Make | Model | MOT index | Fail first time | At 4 to 6 yrs | At 10 to 12 yrs | Tests |
|---|
The 15 best cars at MOT time, allowing for age
Car models with 50,000 or more tests in 2024, ranked by MOT index.
| Rank | Model | MOT index | Fail first time | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Porsche 911 | 36 | 12.1% | 50,455 |
| 2 | Audi Q2 | 62 | 9.7% | 73,583 |
| 3 | Volkswagen T-Roc | 63 | 9.0% | 76,211 |
| 4 | Ford Puma | 68 | 9.1% | 59,400 |
| 5 | MINI Countryman | 70 | 16.1% | 107,115 |
| 6 | Audi Q5 | 70 | 16.2% | 110,763 |
| 7 | Range Rover | 70 | 21.6% | 88,383 |
| 8 | BMW 5 Series | 72 | 20.8% | 211,439 |
| 9 | Audi A6 | 72 | 20.9% | 126,656 |
| 10 | Range Rover Sport | 72 | 20.3% | 117,933 |
| 11 | Volvo XC40 | 72 | 9.8% | 72,365 |
| 12 | Skoda Karoq | 73 | 10.6% | 53,019 |
| 13 | BMW X5 | 73 | 20.8% | 91,070 |
| 14 | Audi TT | 74 | 24.2% | 113,456 |
| 15 | Mazda MX-5 | 74 | 25.7% | 92,657 |
The 15 worst cars at MOT time, allowing for age
| Rank | Model | MOT index | Fail first time | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Citroen DS3 | 145 | 48.0% | 72,100 |
| 2 | Dacia Sandero | 144 | 30.9% | 106,759 |
| 3 | Dacia Duster | 141 | 27.7% | 72,288 |
| 4 | Renault Clio | 136 | 42.8% | 323,936 |
| 5 | Citroen C4 | 133 | 40.1% | 136,115 |
| 6 | Renault Megane | 131 | 45.6% | 106,705 |
| 7 | Peugeot 2008 | 129 | 26.1% | 132,143 |
| 8 | Vauxhall Mokka | 126 | 28.6% | 233,342 |
| 9 | Tesla Model 3 | 125 | 16.1% | 67,653 |
| 10 | Peugeot 207 | 123 | 49.9% | 135,835 |
| 11 | Peugeot 3008 | 122 | 28.7% | 140,988 |
| 12 | SEAT Ibiza | 120 | 34.1% | 194,315 |
| 13 | Nissan Juke | 120 | 30.2% | 315,253 |
| 14 | Peugeot 308 | 120 | 35.9% | 133,199 |
| 15 | Peugeot 208 | 120 | 29.0% | 207,479 |
Vans and pickups
Vans cover far more miles than cars of the same age, so they are ranked separately. The index still compares each with all vehicles of the same age, which is why most score above 100. The Fiat Ducato and Peugeot Boxer lead the table with median mileages well below the other vans, which is consistent with the large number converted into motorhomes.
| Rank | Model | MOT index | Fail first time | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fiat Ducato | 76 | 26.8% | 73,280 |
| 2 | Peugeot Boxer | 84 | 27.4% | 53,891 |
| 3 | Volkswagen Transporter | 106 | 32.1% | 309,182 |
| 4 | Volkswagen Caddy | 109 | 31.6% | 148,660 |
| 5 | Mitsubishi L200 | 109 | 29.7% | 78,581 |
| 6 | Toyota Hilux | 114 | 30.9% | 72,955 |
| 7 | Mercedes-Benz Vito | 118 | 33.3% | 88,034 |
| 8 | Ford Ranger | 121 | 27.7% | 110,509 |
| 9 | Nissan Navara | 126 | 31.9% | 73,418 |
| 10 | Ford Transit Connect | 128 | 34.5% | 168,068 |
| 11 | Ford Transit | 128 | 35.2% | 360,207 |
| 12 | Peugeot Expert | 129 | 33.5% | 55,805 |
| 13 | Renault Kangoo | 142 | 45.8% | 56,342 |
| 14 | Peugeot Partner | 145 | 37.8% | 153,997 |
| 15 | Vauxhall Combo | 146 | 38.7% | 109,654 |
| 16 | Renault Trafic | 147 | 41.7% | 109,028 |
| 17 | Citroen Berlingo | 149 | 41.3% | 188,897 |
| 18 | Vauxhall Vivaro | 152 | 43.4% | 184,921 |
| 19 | Ford Transit Custom | 176 | 22.7% | 83,218 |
Makes ranked
| Rank | Make | MOT index | Fail first time | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bentley | 28 | 9.0% | 22,464 |
| 2 | Porsche | 46 | 13.3% | 177,350 |
| 3 | Lexus | 60 | 16.6% | 166,052 |
| 4 | BMW | 78 | 21.3% | 1,863,938 |
| 5 | Subaru | 79 | 26.1% | 58,986 |
| 6 | Jaguar | 79 | 21.4% | 352,025 |
| 7 | Audi | 80 | 21.9% | 1,720,671 |
| 8 | Land Rover | 82 | 23.4% | 934,645 |
| 9 | MINI | 84 | 23.6% | 808,473 |
| 10 | Honda | 86 | 28.1% | 921,158 |
| 11 | Mercedes-Benz | 88 | 23.2% | 1,722,956 |
| 12 | Saab | 88 | 36.5% | 49,011 |
| 13 | Toyota | 88 | 25.7% | 1,693,362 |
| 14 | Rover | 90 | 34.6% | 30,795 |
| 15 | Skoda | 92 | 23.7% | 793,369 |
| 16 | Mazda | 94 | 27.7% | 534,225 |
| 17 | Suzuki | 94 | 26.8% | 436,346 |
| 18 | Smart | 95 | 28.5% | 74,285 |
| 19 | Volvo | 95 | 25.8% | 592,764 |
| 20 | Volkswagen | 96 | 27.6% | 3,073,603 |
| 21 | MG | 98 | 20.1% | 121,528 |
| 22 | Abarth | 98 | 22.0% | 29,269 |
| 23 | Mitsubishi | 100 | 28.7% | 293,051 |
| 24 | Alfa Romeo | 101 | 32.0% | 71,359 |
| 25 | Hyundai | 103 | 27.0% | 905,762 |
| 26 | SEAT | 104 | 26.0% | 564,548 |
| 27 | Jeep | 104 | 26.7% | 71,373 |
| 28 | Kia | 106 | 26.0% | 956,622 |
| 29 | Fiat | 108 | 32.4% | 785,118 |
| 30 | Ford | 109 | 31.5% | 4,419,170 |
| 31 | Nissan | 113 | 32.2% | 1,646,834 |
| 32 | Vauxhall | 116 | 34.1% | 2,946,953 |
| 33 | Peugeot | 118 | 34.0% | 1,424,124 |
| 34 | Tesla | 119 | 16.7% | 86,384 |
| 35 | Chevrolet | 119 | 45.6% | 57,368 |
| 36 | Isuzu | 124 | 32.4% | 44,103 |
| 37 | Citroen | 126 | 37.0% | 1,013,916 |
| 38 | Renault | 130 | 37.9% | 983,645 |
| 39 | Dacia | 142 | 29.6% | 195,053 |
| 40 | DS | 145 | 30.2% | 44,224 |
| 41 | SsangYong | 152 | 33.1% | 24,415 |
Fail rate by age
The first MOT at three years is failed by about one car in eight. By ten years it is one in three, and it peaks at about 44% at 17 to 19 years. Vehicles of 21 years and over do slightly better, at 37.2%: by then the survivors are the cared-for ones.
| Age at test | Tests | Fail first time |
|---|---|---|
| 0-2 years | 1,511,960 | 11.9% |
| 3 years | 1,755,044 | 12.7% |
| 4 years | 2,166,142 | 14.3% |
| 5 years | 2,439,728 | 16.6% |
| 6 years | 2,389,144 | 19.1% |
| 7 years | 2,654,435 | 22.0% |
| 8 years | 2,636,005 | 25.2% |
| 9 years | 2,465,850 | 28.6% |
| 10 years | 2,204,477 | 31.9% |
| 11 years | 1,914,094 | 34.6% |
| 12 years | 1,677,038 | 37.1% |
| 13 years | 1,568,334 | 39.4% |
| 14 years | 1,486,547 | 41.1% |
| 15 years | 1,186,653 | 42.5% |
| 16 years | 1,163,749 | 43.1% |
| 17 years | 961,384 | 43.6% |
| 18 years | 728,109 | 43.7% |
| 19 years | 554,644 | 43.7% |
| 20 years | 424,432 | 43.2% |
| 21+ years | 1,173,398 | 37.2% |
Petrol, diesel, hybrid and electric
| Fuel | At 3 years | At 4 to 6 years | At 7 to 9 years | At 10 to 12 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Petrol | 11.3% | 15.8% | 24.3% | 33.6% |
| Diesel | 16.7% | 19.0% | 26.3% | 35.2% |
| Hybrid | 10.7% | 13.5% | 18.3% | 23.1% |
| Electric | 13.2% | 16.4% | 27.8% | 33.1% |
Hybrids are the most reliable at every age. Electric cars are not: at their first MOT, 13.2% of electric cars fail, against 11.3% of petrol cars. The reason is tyres. Among vehicles aged three to six, 7.9% of all electric car tests fail on tyres, against 5.1% for petrol, a rate 56% higher. Electric cars fail on brakes less than half as often (1.2% against 2.8%), which fits what regenerative braking does to pad and disc wear, and they have no exhaust to fail on. Electric figures at ten years and over rest on about 10,000 tests and should be read with care.
| Fault area, vehicles aged 3 to 6 | Petrol | Diesel | Hybrid | Electric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tyres | 5.1% | 5.7% | 4.9% | 7.9% |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical | 3.4% | 5.2% | 3.2% | 2.8% |
| Visibility | 3.2% | 3.4% | 3.2% | 2.8% |
| Brakes | 2.8% | 3.8% | 1.4% | 1.2% |
| Suspension | 1.7% | 2.7% | 1.1% | 1.7% |
| Emissions, exhaust and leaks | 0.8% | 2.0% | 0.2% | 0.0% |
Share of all tests in that fuel group, not just failed ones.
What vehicles fail on
| Fault area | Share of failed tests | Share of all tests |
|---|---|---|
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical | 38.9% | 11.0% |
| Suspension | 31.0% | 8.8% |
| Brakes | 23.9% | 6.8% |
| Tyres | 22.7% | 6.4% |
| Visibility | 16.4% | 4.6% |
| Body, chassis and structure | 12.1% | 3.4% |
| Emissions, exhaust and leaks | 11.2% | 3.2% |
| Steering | 7.0% | 2.0% |
| Seat belts and restraints | 3.5% | 1.0% |
| Road wheels | 1.4% | 0.4% |
| Registration plates and VIN | 1.2% | 0.3% |
Three of the top four are things an owner can check on the drive in ten minutes: bulbs, tyres and wipers. See MOT advisories explained, the retest rules and how early you can take the test, or check any vehicle with our free MOT history checker.
Method
- Source. DVSA anonymised MOT tests and results for calendar year 2024, published as open data on data.gov.uk: the result file and the failure item file.
- Scope. Class 4 vehicles (cars, and vans up to 3,000 kg), normal tests only. Retests, abandoned and aborted tests are excluded. That leaves 33,061,372 tests.
- Fail first time. DVSA's initial failure definition: the test result was a fail, or a pass after rectification at the station. The share with an outright fail result was about 22.8%.
- Duplicates. The published 2024 result file repeats rows. We count each test once.
- Model families. On vehicles registered from about 2021, the model field carries trim levels, such as "Corsa SE Premium". We group these into families, so a model's figures cover all its generations and trims. Families with 20,000 or more tests are listed; those with 50,000 or more have their own page.
- MOT index. For each model we work out how many first-time fails would be expected if vehicles of each age failed at the national rate for that age. The index is actual fails divided by expected fails, times 100. It removes the effect of age, which otherwise makes every new model look good and every discontinued one look bad. It does not adjust for mileage, use or how well vehicles are maintained, so it measures the cars and their owners together.
- Fault areas. Failure-level defects only (major and dangerous). Advisories and minor defects are not counted. Each test is counted once per area.
- Age. Whole years between the date of first use and the test.
Use this data
The index is free to quote and reproduce with a link to this page. Download the full table (CSV): 419 model families with tests, fail rate, MOT index and fail rate by age band.
Suggested credit: Logbook.co.uk MOT Failure Index 2024, from DVSA open data. Press enquiries: corrections@logbook.co.uk.
FAQs
What percentage of cars fail their MOT?
In 2024, 28.3% of MOT tests on cars and light vans ended in a first-time fail, counting tests that passed only after a repair during the test. About 22.8% ended with an outright fail result.
Which car is most likely to pass its MOT?
Allowing for age, the best-performing car model with 50,000 or more tests in 2024 was the Porsche 911, with an MOT index of 36 where 100 is average.
What is the most common MOT failure?
Lighting and electrical faults, found in 38.9% of failed tests, followed by suspension (31.0%), brakes (23.9%) and tyres (22.7%).
Do electric cars fail the MOT more often?
At their first MOT at three years old, 13.2% of electric cars failed first time in 2024, against 11.3% of petrol cars and 10.7% of hybrids. Electric cars fail on tyres far more often and on brakes far less often.
At what age do cars start failing the MOT?
The fail rate rises every year from the first test: 12.7% at three years, about a quarter at eight years and about a third at ten years.
Sources
data.gov.ukDVSA: anonymised MOT tests and resultsgov.ukMOT inspection manual: cars and passenger vehiclesgov.ukGetting an MOTSource: DVSA, anonymised MOT tests and results, 2024. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Analysis by Logbook.co.uk.