Logbook · publication

BMW X1 MOT Failure Rate: 17.2% Fail First Time (2024 Data)

17.2% fail first time, from 107,311 tests in 2024. Fail rate by age, the faults it fails on and what to check before the test.

BMW X1 MOT Failure Rate: 17.2% Fail First Time (2024 Data)

Direct answer: In 2024, 17.2% of BMW X1 MOT tests ended in a first-time fail: 18,510 of 107,311 tests. The figure for all cars and light vans was 28.3%. Allowing for age, the X1 scores 75 on our MOT index, where 100 is the average for vehicles of the same age: clearly better than average. It ranks 18 of 133 car models with 50,000 or more tests.

"Fail first time" follows DVSA's definition of an initial failure: a fail, or a pass only after a defect was repaired during the test. Retests are excluded.

BMW X1 MOT fail rate by age

Age at testX1All vehiclesDifferenceX1 tests
3 years (first MOT)9.1%12.7%-3.6 pts7,210
4 to 6 years12.0%16.8%-4.8 pts39,235
7 to 9 years17.2%25.2%-7.9 pts26,623
10 to 12 years27.9%34.3%-6.4 pts19,420
13 years and over30.0%41.5%-11.5 pts7,938

The X1 beats or matches the average at every age we can measure, by the widest margin at 13 years and over (-11.5 points).

What the BMW X1 fails on

Share of failed X1 tests with at least one failure-level defect in each area. A test can fail in more than one area, so the columns do not add up to 100%.

Fault areaFailed X1 testsAll failed testsDifference
Tyres36.8%22.7%+14.0 pts
Lamps, reflectors and electrical25.6%38.9%-13.3 pts
Suspension21.8%31.0%-9.2 pts
Brakes17.0%23.9%-6.9 pts
Visibility15.5%16.4%-0.9 pts
Emissions, exhaust and leaks5.7%11.2%-5.5 pts

The most common reason is tyres, present in 36.8% of failed X1 tests. Against other vehicles, the X1 is most over-represented on tyres (+14.0 points). It is least likely to fail on lamps and electrics (-13.3 points).

Before the test: what to check on a X1

  • Tyres. The legal minimum tread is 1.6 mm across the central three-quarters of the tyre, around its whole circumference. Check for cuts, bulges and exposed cord, including the inner edges you can only see with the steering turned.
  • Lamps, reflectors and electrical. Walk round the vehicle with the lights on: dipped and main beam, sidelights, indicators, brake lights, fog and reversing lamps and both number plate lamps. A blown bulb is the most common MOT fail of all and the cheapest to fix beforehand. Check the horn works and that no airbag, ABS or engine warning lamp stays lit.
  • Suspension. Listen for knocks over bumps and look for a corner sitting low. Broken coil springs, worn ball joints and bushes, and leaking shock absorbers are the usual findings. None can be fixed on the day, so have a suspect noise looked at first.

You can take the test up to a month, minus a day, before the certificate runs out and keep the same renewal date. See how early you can MOT and the retest rules if it fails.

Age and mileage at test

Half of all BMW X1 tests in 2024 were on vehicles aged 7 years or more, and the median odometer reading was 54,600 miles. Fail rates rise steeply with both: across all vehicles, 12.7% fail at 3 years old and 41.5% at 13 and over.

Buying a used X1?

Run the registration through our free MOT history checker before you view it. Look for repeat advisories in the fault areas above, especially tyres, and for mileage that climbs steadily from test to test. Then check the paperwork with our guide to verifying BMW service history.

How the BMW range compares

ModelTestsFail first timeMOT index (100 = average for age)
3 Series498,98524.9%81
1 Series399,31923.9%85
5 Series211,43920.8%72
2 Series125,95315.9%82
X1107,31117.2%75
4 Series106,69316.2%76
X3104,81820.1%82
X591,07020.8%73

See every model in the MOT Failure Index or all BMW models.

FAQs

What percentage of BMW X1 MOT tests fail?

In 2024, 17.2% of BMW X1 MOT tests ended in a first-time fail, from 107,311 tests. The average for all cars and light vans was 28.3%.

What does the BMW X1 fail its MOT on most often?

The most common fault area is tyres, found in 36.8% of failed X1 tests, followed by lamps and electrics (25.6%) and suspension (21.8%).

Is the BMW X1 reliable at MOT time?

Allowing for the age of the vehicles tested, the X1 scores 75 on our MOT index, where 100 is average. That is clearly better than average.

About this data

Figures cover every class 4 MOT test (cars and light vans up to 3,000 kg) recorded by DVSA in 2024: 33,061,372 normal tests in all. Model names in the raw data include trim levels on newer vehicles, so we group them into model families; all generations of the X1 are counted together. The MOT index divides the number of first-time fails by the number expected for vehicles of the same ages, so an older fleet is not penalised for being old. It does not adjust for mileage or use. Full method on the index page.

Sources

data.gov.ukDVSA: anonymised MOT tests and resultsgov.ukMOT inspection manual: cars and passenger vehicles

Source: DVSA, anonymised MOT tests and results, 2024. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Analysis by Logbook.co.uk.

Miss a deadline, pay the fine.

One email a week. Every new rule, deadline and record-keeping change that affects you.

Logbook.co.uk is an independent UK publication edited by Jamie Dawson. Guides are checked against current UK legislation and primary sources from gov.uk, HSE, ICO, DVLA, DVSA, CAA and trade bodies. Always confirm against the underlying source before acting. Nothing on this site is legal advice.